Elena’s phone vibrates before her alarm at 5:12 a.m. She reaches for it because messages that arrive before dawn tend to matter.
Shift allocation updated.*
Base rate: $31.40/hr
Adjustment factors applied: -$2.10/hr
Net rate: $29.30/hr
*Based on recent attendance volatility, performance signals, and local labor supply conditions.
Last week her base rate was $33. The week before it was $35. There is no supervisor to call to ask why she keeps getting downgraded, no office where she can go to complain. All Elena can do is click a small blue “learn more” button. She has begun to think of her work not as a wage, exactly, but as an assessment of her current economic worth, relative to her coworkers, recalculated daily. A second notification pings.
Access yesterday’s earnings early.
Available now: $86.20
Fee: $9.75
APR equivalent: 391 percent
There’s fine print here, too: “Based on your projected earnings and spending patterns.”
She stares at the message for a moment. The money is already hers, or will be, but not yet—not in the way that matters. The offer lingers, framed as convenience rather than cost, a small bridge across the gap between what she has earned and what she can access. She dismisses the notification and gets ready for work.
In the kitchen, Elena pours coffee into a chipped mug, looks at her empty fridge, and opens a grocery app. Milk: $5.89. Bread: $4.76. Eggs: $7.12. The note at the bottom of the screen reads: “Price reflects real-time demand, location, and personalized offer conditions.”
Yesterday, it pains her to remember, the eggs were $6.48. But the system has learned when she shops, what she buys, when she is tired, and for how long she hesitates with the cursor over the “add to cart” button. The system seems to be able to calculate, with increasing precision, the upper limit of what she will pay.
At the hospital where she works, Elena scans a QR code with her phone to alert the system that she’s arrived, and not too early. Last week, she tried to scan the code more than seven minutes before her start time, which dinged her score by half a point.
The assignments begin immediately, appearing as stacked notifications on her phone’s lock screen. Room 312 needs water. Room 318 is confused, pulling at the IV. Room 322’s discharge is delayed. Elena moves quickly. Her care is compressed into gestures that she hopes register as sufficient to her patients: a smile, a sentence, a touch that ends before it becomes a conversation.
The hospital, she has learned, records sounds, motions, and facial expressions. It translates her work into a series of measurable signals—ones that will shape tomorrow’s rate. The clip-on badge that hangs from her shirt tracks not just where she is in the facility, but how long she spends in the bathroom. She tries to be quick and not to drink too much.
At 10:47 a.m., her phone buzzes: “Bonus applied: +$0.60/hr (temporary).” The raise lasts forty-three minutes—a brief micro-expansion of her purchasing power.
In Room 376, something seems off. The vitals are low but not terrible. The patient is responsive but not quick. His breath is shallow. Elena wonders if he’s always this way. There’s no one to ask. She tries to see what the last nurse noted in the chart, and increases the patient’s acuity score so he’ll qualify for more staffing during the next few shifts. She messes around with a few numbers to no avail. The staffing matrix won’t budge. He is at severity level 4.6, even though she worries he should really be at 8.
Almost immediately, she regrets these extra minutes spent with the charts. Her phone pings: “Productivity score: weak. Improve pace to avoid penalty of -$0.30/hr.”
In the break room, Jameela stares at her phone. “They’re charging me more for insulin this week,” she says to Elena.
“How much?”
“Three dollars.”
Elena nods. Three dollars is not a lot until it is—until it accumulates across weeks and other necessities.
After leaving the hospital, Elena steps out into the fading light and opens her ride-hailing app. She orders a car to the grocery store that partners with the grocery app. Before she can put her phone away, she hears Jameela behind her.
“Are you going to the store, too? Want to share a car? I just ordered one.”
“Me too,” Elena says.
They hold up their phones and compare fares. Two rides, to the same destination, requested at almost the same moment, are priced $3.80 apart. Jameela’s is cheaper, so Elena cancels hers. As she taps the button, she feels a small catch of unease: Will the app remember this and punish her later with higher prices?
They arrive and part ways. Elena notes that the shelf prices are digital approximations of what she will pay. At checkout, the scanner resolves everything—her basket, her profile, her inferred willingness to pay. Milk. Eggs. Bread. Spinach. $24.63.
Elena hesitates. She won’t have time to come back tomorrow. Her credit card goes through after a brief delay, as if something elsewhere is being recalculated—her balance against predicted expenses, her wages against anticipated need. [...]
*****
Elena is fictional, but not fanciful. Her day reflects a composite of experiences that researchers and workers, including both authors, have identified across the contemporary labor market: the gigification of healthcare, the real-time personalization of wages and prices, and the use of algorithmic and machine-learning systems to shape behavior and mete out discipline. Dubal’s work on
algorithmic wage discrimination has identified opaque, personalized, and variable pay as a technology of labor control. Wells and her co-authors have traced these platform logics into
nursing, where apps allocate shifts, set pay, monitor performance, and fragment responsibility for patient care. Joint work by both of us and our colleagues at Fairwork situates these developments within a broader shift toward AI-mediated management. Related research on surveillance prices and wages shows how the same data-driven logic can individualize both what people earn and what they pay, including studies by Wells and her colleagues on the mechanics of surveillance pricing at
Instacart and
Uber. The result is not only precarious economic uncertainty, but also poorer quality of life and health—for workers and patients alike.
Precarious life allows algorithmic wages and algorithmic prices to meet, and it is also what they produce. This kind of algorithmically mediated life produces what Dubal calls “predetermined purchasing power.” Purchasing power is usually understood as what remains after prices are subtracted from wages. But Elena’s world reverses this sequence. Before Elena acts, the range of choices available to her has already been narrowed by what firms have inferred about her. Her wage has been adjusted toward what she is predicted to accept. The price of necessities has been adjusted toward what she is predicted to tolerate. Her rent, fees, credit, and access to her own wages are shaped by calculations about whether she can wait, whether she can leave, whether she has savings, and whether she has alternatives.
The result is not simply precarity, but an iterative constraint. Rather than just limiting her purchasing power, these algorithmic wage and pricing systems predetermine what her purchasing power can ever be. A low wage allocated today does not merely leave Elena with less money; it produces data about what she will accept tomorrow. A high grocery price does not merely reduce her balance; it produces data about what she will pay when she is tired, rushed, and hungry. A late rent payment does not just trigger a fee; it produces data about her risk. A payday advance bridges a gap, but it also confirms the existence of the gap as a market opportunity, perhaps influencing her wages the next day—ensuring she works harder and longer for less. The system learns from the injuries it helps to create.
Predetermined purchasing power names the condition in which wages, prices, rents, fees, credit, and debt are adjusted around a person before she acts, so that what looks like choice is often only the final step in a process that produces constraint. It is not the old company store, but it has a similar effect: to capture a worker’s life from all sides. Today, the ledger is distributed across apps, platforms, brokers, employers, landlords, and lenders. It does not need one owner. It only needs the same data, the same asymmetry, and the same person with little power to choose otherwise.
by Veena Dubal and Katie J. Wells, Dissent |
Read more:
Image: Ben Jones[ed. See also:
A Media History of the Infinite Feed (Reboot):]
*****
Infinite scroll was a fundamental technical innovation behind today’s “For You pages,” or customized algorithmic feeds. As infinite scroll became implemented across all the major social networks, it allowed platforms to react to the information they gathered from users in real time. Building on its earlier EdgeRank system, in 2013 Facebook transitioned to a machine learning recommendation algorithm that used
“over a thousand different factors” to sort posts in the platform’s News Feed, based on users’ predicted engagement. Infinite scroll meant that Facebook could deliver recent posts in small continuous batches — they would appear for users naturally, as long as they had a continuous Internet connection, maximizing engagement and minimizing conscious choice to load more content. But furthermore, delivering content piecemeal meant that Facebook’s recommendation engine could react to rapidly-updated data about posts’ global performance on the social network — the likelihood of all of Facebook’s user’s engagement with the post — but also to rapidly-updated data about the likelihood of the particular user’s engagement, based on real-time “likes”, “comments,” and “shares” of the posts they saw, possibly from the just-delivered batch.
The infinite scroll-powered feed opened the door for the rise of a sharp critique of Big Tech’s capture of people’s emotional states. In 2019, Harvard Business School professor Shoshana Zuboff would publish
The Age of Surveillance Capitalism (Profile, 2019), which argued that platforms close tracking of people’s activity allowed to extract “behavioral surplus,” data that could be turned into “prediction products” and marketed to advertisers, insurers, and political campaigns interested in shaping people’s future behaviors. The infinite feed was a key medium for this task — it allowed platforms to collect “fresh” data about users, allowing ad systems to react instantaneously. But furthermore, these ads were delivered not just based on users’ demographic characteristics — for example, whether one is a 31 year-old graduate student in the Bay Area — but also on data that purportedly represented their psychological
states, their behaviors and attitudes to immediately preceding content — whether they are hopeful, sad, or lonely. The infinite feed enabled surveillance capitalism’s move from demography to behavioral prediction, and it became the center of controversies around emotional influence like the Cambridge Analytica scandal.
Infinite feeds today are as ubiquitous as the critique of their psychological effects. Their history shows us, however, that their emergence was far from natural or inevitable — but the result of technical disputes, corporate power plays, and competing visions of what the Web should be. It also shows us how infinite scroll transformed not just what the Web looked like, but what it fundamentally
did: to our attention, our behavior, and our politics. It materialized the worst fears of “push” critics, making the Web an engine of real-time, monetizable interaction, far from the library of static documents that some had tried to protect. But it exceeded even the hopes of “push” enthusiasts. Reshaping the temporality of client-server connections turned out to mean more than rapid content delivery; it refashioned online experience based on the immediate collection of behavioral data, laying the groundwork for a new wave of scrutiny: of algorithmic manipulation and psychological exploitation. Infinite scroll did not just change how we consume information — it radically changed how we understand its power over our minds.